Pickle’s Pie Shop – Homemade Pies in Big Bear Lake

Pickle’s Pie Shop is known for its handmade sweet and savory pies, buttery crusts, seasonal flavors, and cozy cottage-style atmosphere in Big Bear City. It has developed a strong local following and is especially popular for unique creations like Bourbon Pecan, seasonal fruit pies, Chocolate Checkmate, and take-and-bake savory pot pies.

Pickle’s offers rotating sweet and savory pies including fruit pies, seasonal combinations, pecan pies, chocolate pies, apple varieties, and frozen take-and-bake pot pies. Seasonal flavors change throughout the year depending on ingredients and availability.

Yes. Pickle’s is a favorite stop for dessert lovers, families, cozy cabin weekends, rainy day outings, and holiday trips. Many visitors make it part of their Big Bear tradition and recommend arriving early because popular pies often sell out by lunch time.

Pickle’s Pie Shop is located at 829 W Big Bear Blvd, Big Bear City, CA 92314, in the former Madeline’s building near the east side of Big Bear Valley.

Not exactly. Pickle’s is located in Big Bear City, east of The Village area in Big Bear Lake. Guests staying near The Village should expect a short drive across town to reach the shop.

Yes. Families often stop in for pie slices, whole pies to take back to the cabin, holiday desserts, and savory pot pies. The whimsical cottage setting and rotating menu make it a fun stop for both kids and adults.

Yes. Guests can purchase whole pies, and advance ordering is recommended because many flavors sell quickly. Some visitors reserve pies ahead of time to ensure availability.

Yes. Pickle’s Pie Shop is a family-owned bakery run by a husband-and-wife team that makes a limited number of pies each day rather than producing large batches. Because of their small-batch approach and strong local following, popular flavors often sell out by late morning or early afternoon depending on the season and visitor traffic. Arriving early or placing an order in advance is recommended, especially during holidays and busy weekends.

Whole pies, seasonal fruit pies, pecan pies, chocolate pies, and pie slices from Pickle’s make popular cabin desserts. Many guests pair them with coffee, hot chocolate, fireside evenings, or holiday meals back at their vacation rental.